📚 CBSE Grade-10 Study Guide Open in the Study Guide single page app →
HomeEnglish Language & Literature

English Language & Literature — CBSE Class 10 board question

Q1. [6]
How does the method of the seagull's mother to teach her child to be independent contrast with Amanda's mother's constant nagging ? Examine how this affects the emotional responses of the seagull and Amanda. ('Two Stories about Flying' and 'Amanda!')
Previously asked in CBSE board exam
2026 2/3/1 Q10(a)
Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 · 2026-06-15 07:19 · grounding rag
Model Answer

Method of Teaching — Contrast:

The seagull's mother uses a strategic, loving method to make her young one fly. She withholds food, ignores his cries, and then tempts him with fish just out of reach — forcing him to dive instinctively. Her tough love is purposeful: she knows he can fly and engineers the moment.

Amanda's mother, in contrast, constantly nags her — stop slouching, don't eat chocolate, don't bite nails, don't hunch. She imposes rules without understanding Amanda's emotional need for freedom and imagination.

Effect on Emotional Responses:

The seagull's fear transforms into exhilaration and triumph. Once he dives, terror gives way to joy — he soars, joins his family, and "completely forgot that he had not always been able to fly." The experience builds confidence.

Amanda, however, retreats into fantasy — she imagines herself a mermaid, an orphan roaming freely, Rapunzel in a tower. The constant nagging makes her sulky and withdrawn, escaping mentally because she cannot escape physically.

Conclusion: The seagull's mother trusts nature and guides through action; Amanda's mother controls through words — one builds independence, the other stifles it.

Source: Chapter 3 — His First Flight; Amanda! (First Flight, Class X)

---

Explanation
If a question refers to an image, map, graph or diagram that is not shown here, open the Study Guide single page app, go to Library and find the actual CBSE question paper. The original papers are also available on the CBSE website: cbse.gov.in.
Previous-year CBSE Grade 10 board exam questions, organised by subject and chapter, each with a model answer — free to read and print.